updated
To collect and use the Torn Treasure Maps in RDR2 you will have to find and kill two unique Hermits, both of which can be found within the world of Red Dead Redemption II. Each one contains one half of a treasure map that will lead to the unique pistol Otis Miller’s Revolver.
The order in which you collect the map halves does not matter. It will only affect which map half is named "Torn Treasure Map 1" and "Torn Treasure Map 2."
Spoiler Warning: You cannot get the treasure maps lead until after the Epilogue. While you can get the map itself before then, it is best to just collect it all at the end of the game. Images may contain story spoilers.
advertisem*nt
Torn Treasure Map 1
The Male Hermit is found on the far eastern side of the map, north of the town Annesburg. Along the right-hand road north of Annesburg is Manito Glade. There you will find the hermit’s home surrounded by a fence and "Keep Out" signs.
When you approach, he will shout at you and threaten to shoot at you. You'll have to kill him if you want to be able to enter his home and collect the unique shotgun simply called the Rare Shotgun. You must pick it up now, or you will not be able to collect it later. Once inside, you'll find one half of the Torn Treasure Map inside a drawer in the house.
Torn Treasure Map 2
The Female Hermit is found on the western side of West Elizabeth. Her home is far northwest of Wallace Station. Follow Little Creek River into the mountains and her home is in the woods off to the right.
She will sick her three dogs upon you when you get close to her home. Kill all three of the dogs and the hermit herself so you may safely collect the second half of the Torn Treasure Map. Similar to the first half, the map piece is inside the house inside a drawer.
advertisem*nt
The two map halves will make the whole treasure map, pictured below.
Where to Find the Torn Treasure Map Treasure
Once you collect both halves of the Torn Treasure Map, head down to the town of Armadillo. Northwest of the town, along the state line near Rattlesnake Hollow, you will find a small cave entrance.
Inside the cave is Otis Miller’s treasure. Open it up to collect the rare Otis Miller’s Revolver, as well as six "erotic photographs."
